We were two broken hearts
In the darkness we both pretend
In my mind you were her
In your fantasies I was him
But hearts heal, guess
Cause tonight I feel something new
And I realize by the look
in your eyes
You're feeling it too
Let's leave the lights on tonight
It's you I wanna hold tight
Why don't I just close the door?
We won't pretend anymore
We'll let those old memories die
We'll be just you and I
Somehow it all feels so right
Let's leave the lights on to night
I was just using you,
and you were just using me
We made love in the dark,
but only to fantasies
Oh, I wanted her,
now I find that I'm wanting you
An d the way you touched me, girl,
I believe you're wanting me too
Let's leave the lights on tonight
It's you I wanna hold tight
Why don't I just close the door
We won't pretend anymore
We'll let those old memories die
We'll be just you and I
Somehow it all feels so right
Let's leave the lights on tonight
Let's leave the lights on tonight
It's you I want the whole time
Why don't I just close the door?